Little Mike's Pizza

Discover Little Mike’s Pizza - a hidden culinary treasure at 9843 Pines Blvd, Pembroke Pines, FL 33024, United States. As part of the Taste & Tell Reviews series, I’m thrilled to introduce this neighborhood favorite that’s redefining casual dining in South Florida. For those searching for the best restaurants in Pembroke Pines or authentic local dining experiences, this cozy spot deserves a prime spot on your list.

Little Mike’s Pizza isn’t just another pizza joint - it’s a celebration of old-school craftsmanship blended with a modern twist. Every pie is hand-tossed, baked to golden perfection, and topped with the freshest ingredients. The moment you walk in, the aroma of bubbling cheese and roasted garlic fills the air, promising a meal worth every calorie.

Among their must-try items, the Classic New York Cheese Pizza stands tall - thin, crispy, and loaded with a generous layer of melted mozzarella that stretches with every bite. Another favorite, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, balances a perfect kick of spice with creamy ranch drizzle, earning rave reviews from regulars. And if you’re craving comfort, don’t miss the Garlic Knots, which locals call “the softest, butteriest in town.”

One Google reviewer mentioned, “Little Mike’s Pizza reminds me of home - the dough is perfect, the sauce is tangy, and the staff always greet you like family.” Another shared, “It’s my go-to place after work. Affordable, fast, and consistently delicious.”

Inside, the atmosphere is relaxed and inviting - red-brick walls, family photos, and warm lighting create the feel of a true Italian-American eatery. Whether you’re dining solo or bringing the whole crew, it’s the kind of place that feels personal. The friendly team is always ready with a smile, and service is impressively quick, even during rush hours.

What makes Little Mike’s Pizza special isn’t just its food, but its heart. This family-run restaurant takes pride in consistency and community. They’re known for their customer-first service, generous portions, and affordable pricing - plus, they’re pet-friendly for those grabbing a bite on the patio.

If you’re in Pembroke Pines and searching for authentic pizza in South Florida, Little Mike’s Pizza delivers quality, comfort, and charm in every slice. From its friendly staff to its flavorful menu, this local gem continues to win hearts - one pizza at a time. Call +1 954-613-3604 to order or stop by to discover why so many locals call it the best-kept secret in the neighborhood.